Session 1: Exploring EvaRIO context
This first session aims at locating EvaRIO within the more general framework of impact evaluation of science. Because EvaRIO uses case studies in the BMS domain, the session includes an insight on approaches used to evaluate the impacts of the health science. Another critical issue concerns the interactions of RIs with industry.
Chair: Thierry Burger-Helmchen |
| 9.00 -9.30 |
Ex-post and ex-ante indicators of pan-European relevance of Research Infrastructures"
Giorgio Rossi (Chair of ESFRI, working group on indicators, Italy)
download |
| 9.30 -10.00 |
Evaluation approaches in the BMS field: The transformative impact of outcomes measurements on the quality and economics of surgical care.
Lee L. Swanstrom (Chief Innovations Officer at IHU Strasbourg & Clinical Professor of Surgery at Oregon Health & Science University)
download |
| 10.00 -10.30 |
Industry-RI interactions: lessons from the EIRIISS project
Kate Barker (Manchester Institute of Innovation & Manchester Business School)
download |
| 10.30 -11.00 |
Coffee break
|
Session 2: Alternative approaches for evaluating impacts of RI, e-infrastructures and technological platforms
This session puts EvaRIO results into perspective by presenting alternative evaluation approaches dedicated to RIs, technological platforms as well as distributed einfrastructures.
Chair: Emmanuel Muller |
| 11.00 -11.30 |
Landscape of large scale infrastructure innovation/impact methodologies. Report on Big Science and Innovation, Technopolis 2013.
Claire Dougan-McCallie (Head of STFC Impact Evaluation) and Frank Zuijdam (Technopolis)
download |
| 11.30 -12.00 |
Evaluating the impacts of medical imagery platforms on medical research.
Stéphane Lhuillery (ICN Metz & BETA)
download |
| 12.00 -12.30 |
Evaluating e-Infrastructures and e-Infrastructures projects: Lessons learned from the ERINA+ approach
Andrea Manieri (ERINA+ Coordinator)
download |
| 12.30 -13.00 |
The role of research infrastructures on international collaborations.
Mickael Pero (ISI, Karlsruhe) |
Session 3: Alternative approaches for evaluating RI impacts: Capturing knowledge creation dimensions
This session is about alternative evaluation approaches presenting similarities with EvaRIO concerns, namely the search for indicators able to represent the evolution of the "capacity" and/or gain in competence of actors involved in research activities. Those approaches could open promising avenues for improving the evaluation of RI impacts.
Chair: Jean-Alain Héraud |
| 14.00 -14.30 |
Looking for indicators of outputs and outcomes in a systematic of institutional evaluation. The case of the Brazilian synchrotron LNLS.
Sergio Salles Filho (Manchester Institute of Innovation Research - University of Campinas - Brazil)
download |
| 14.30 -15.00 |
Evaluating R&D networks with social network analysis tools
Lorenzo Cassi (OST & CES - University Paris I Sorbonne)
download |
| 15.00 -15.30 |
Using science metrics to assess the impact of research grant allocation
Nicolas Carayol (University Bordeaux IV)
download |
| 15.30 -16.00 |
Epistemic capacity in research environments: a framework for process evaluation.
Tomas Hellström (Lund University)
download |
Round Table
16.00 -17.00 |
Gaps and need for new tools to evaluate the economic impacts of RIs
Moderator: Patrick Llerena
with participation of:
- Jean-Pierre Caminade (TGIR, French Research Ministry)
- Patrick Cohendet (HEC Montréal, Canada)
- Jacques Demotes (INSERM & ECRIN)
- Claire Dougan-McCallie (Head of STFC Impact Evaluation)
- Maria Douka (DG Research, EU)
- Dino Moras (IGBMC & INSTRUCT)
- Jeannette Ridder-Numan (Ministry of Education, Culture and Science, Netherlands)
- Giorgio Rossi (Chair of ESFRI, working group on indicators, Italy)
- Sergio Salles Filho (University of Campinas - Brazil)
|
| 17.00 |
Concluding get together and drinks (Salle commune, next to the Amphi commun) |
